Agenda

Tuesday, Nov. 19

Morning Session

8 a.m. Registration
 9 a.m. Welcome and Workshop Objectives
Nick Benardini | Planetary Protection Officer, NASA Headquarters
Stefan Green | Associate Professor, Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Infectious Diseases, Rush University
Silvio Sinibaldi | Planetary Protection Officer, European Space Agency

Presentation Slides
9:30 a.m. Break
 9:45 a.m. Session One Presentations: Safety Critical Decision Making - Recording
Alexis M. Hamilton | Assistant Professor, Department of Food Science and Technology, Virginia Tech
"Use of Omics Methods to Enhance Food Safety"

Shino Suzuki | Chief Scientist, Geobiology and Astrobiology Laboratory, RIKEN, ISAS/JAXA
"MMX and Low-Concentration Metagenomics on Extremophilic Microorganisms"

Kasthuri Venkateswaran | Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Retired, Adjunct Professor, Dept. of Space Studies, University of North Dakota
"Advancing Shotgun Metagenomics and Digital PCR Assays to Meet Future Planetary Protection Requirements"

Abstract: The NASA Research program funded-project seeks to develop and validate metagenomic methodologies using digital PCR (dPCR) and shotgun metagenomic sequencing to enhance and augment existing culture-based Planetary Protection (PP) protocols. Traditional NASA assays primarily detected a limited range of organisms, often missing PP-relevant microbes (e.g., anaerobic, psychrophilic, radiation-resistant species). The metagenomics/dPCR framework might overcame this limitation by providing comprehensive microbial detection across diverse domains of life, even in "ultra-low biomass" samples typical of spacecraft and associated environments. These samples posed unique challenges, as low microbial content and high contamination risks complicated analysis. To address these challenges, we employed mock microbial communities, nucleic acid spike-ins, and rigorous validation across all sample processing stages. This framework aimed to integrate metagenomics into NASA’s standard PP practices, supporting spacecraft cleanliness and reducing forward contamination risks. The outcomes supported more efficient microbial reduction strategies, enabling safer and more accurate space exploration.

Alexander Manhert | Medical University of Graz
"Metagenomic Methods to Feed Probability of Contamination Used in Planetary Protection: the JUICE Case Study"

Abstract: The European Space Agency (ESA) and Committee on Space Research (COSPAR) have established planetary protection requirements for Category III & IV missions to Europa and Enceladus. These requirements necessitate a probability assessment of inadvertent contamination by viable organisms transported by spacecraft to subsurface liquid oceans, with a threshold of 1x10-4. Currently, there are no standardized models for assessing this probability. Our objective was to leverage metagenomic analyses to estimate values for several poorly understood parameters, including: 1) Bioburden at launch, 2) Cruise survival, 3) Organism viability and proliferation before, during, and after subsurface transfer. We present preliminary results from the JUICE case study, which provide insights into these parameters and propose how metagenomic approaches can be integrated into mission-critical decision-making processes in the future.

11:20 a.m. Break
11:30 a.m. Session Two Presentations: Microbial Dark Matter - Recording
Bernard O. Palsson | University of California San Diego
"Modularization of Bacterial Transcriptomes Leads to the Annotation of Genes of Unknown Molecular Function to a Cellular Process"

Abstract: Starting in 2013, a large number of RNAseq data sets appeared in public data repositories for bacterial transcirptomes. This growth in these data sets demanded development of novel big data analytic approaches. We discovered that when ICA (independent component analysis) is applied to compendia of bacterial transcriptomes it leads to the definition of 'independently modulated sets of genes,' or iModulons. iModulons can correspond to known regulons, but often lead to discovery of new regulatory modalities. Surprisingly, most iModulons contain y-genes (ie genes of unknown function) leading to gene annotations to a cellular function. Once a y-gene is associated with an iModulon and a cellular function, focused hypotheses can be formulated about their molecular function. Specific cases will be presented.

Jonathan E. Allen | Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
"Addressing Bioinformatics Challenges in Pathogen Agnostic Detection From Metagenomic Sequencing"

Todd DeSantis | Resilient Biotics
"Durable Provisional Categorization of DNA From Mucosal Surfaces"


Abstract:
Vertebrates carry microorganisms concentrated on their mucosal surfaces.  The upper respiratory tract (URT) as the primary interface for sensing and responding to aerosolized microbes from our immediate environments. Culturing the aerobes from nasal swabs allows partial discovery of the diversity present compared to molecular profiling by DNA sequencing.  Not surprisingly, most DNA molecules do not match confidently into an existing taxon.  Thus, we utilized the StrainSelect reference database (PMID: 36814618) which provides durable provisional taxonomic categories where formal Latin nomenclature has not yet evolved. This approach enabled robust comparisons of microbial abundance across biospecimens, research sites, and timeframes.  The ability to scale and extend this system to be generalizable to categorize microbial dark matter based on arrays of protein domains encoded in metagenomic assemblies will be discussed.  From this type of large scale database, associations can be made between vertebrate respiratory diseases and recurring dark-matter entities.

12:00 p.m. Lunch

Afternoon Session

1:30 p.m. Breakout Session One: Safety Critical Decision Making
Breakout Session Two: Microbial Dark Matter
4 p.m. Break
4:30 p.m. Summary of Breakout Sessions and Closing Comments
5:30 p.m. End of Day One

Wednesday, Nov. 20

Morning Session

8 a.m. Session Introduction
8:25 a.m. Session Three Presentations: Low Biomass - Recording
Chairs:
Christina Davis | McGill University
Maria-Paz Zorzano | Centro de Astrobiología

Christopher E. Carr | Georgia Institute of Technology
"Low Biomass Metagenomics and Implications for Planetary Protection"

Abstract: Cell counts in cleanrooms, like extreme environments, are low, making adequate recovery for nucleic-acid-based planetary protection (PP) monitoring challenging. We utilized low-input metagenomics (sub 1-ng libraries) to perform Illumina-based metagenomic sequencing from a transect in the hyper-arid region of the Atacama Desert. Nanopore sequencing offers accessible amplification-free sequencing not limited to short reads, and may also be used on future missions to detect forward contamination or ancestrally-related life. However, at present, its input requirements, typically up to 1 microgram, are challenging. In prior work, we demonstrated detection of a target microbe down to 2 pg of input DNA. We highlight prior and future strategies and opportunities to advance nanopore sequencing for PP applications, which will have important benefits in other contexts, including for science and crew health studies in space by astronauts, where current in situ sequencing is limited to culture-based workflows. We foresee metagenomics as a critical tool for enabling future robotic life detection missions and validating PP strategies on the moon in support of future human exploration of Mars. Finally, we propose ways in which metagenomics can inform integration of microbial growth potential into PP policies.

Sophie A. Simon | University of Duisburg-Essen
"Low-Biomass Nanopore Metagenomics"

Abstract: Nanopore-based environmental metagenomics is often constrained by the requirement of high amounts of input DNA (1-3 µg). Here, we demonstrate the successful application of DNA quantities below these recommended levels (down to 1 ng) and explored its impact on sequencing quality, community composition, assembly accuracy, and the recovery of metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs). We generated 27 Nanopore metagenomes using a microbial community standard, varying input DNA from 1000 ng down to 1 ng in nine input levels in triplicates. Our results show that read quality and mapping accuracy remains equally high across all input levels, with species' relative abundances remaining stable down to 50 ng. Remarkably, high-quality MAGs (> 95% completeness and < 5% contamination) are recoverable with as little as 35 ng of DNA. Even at the lowest levels (1 ng), Nanopore reads combined with Illumina data significantly enhance hybrid assemblies for recovery of large genome fragments. When applied to real environmental samples, our protocol enables low biomass Nanopore metagenomics from small sample quantities and reduce strain heterogeneity, thereby improving assembly and genome reconstruction even down to 7.x ng. These results demonstrate that Nanopore sequencing can successfully be performed with low amounts of environmental DNA, without compromising genome recovery and consequently offer new possibilities for advancing microbiome research, especially in low-biomass environments.

Scott Tighe | University of Vermont
"Requirements for Assessing Ultra-Low Biomass for Genomic Analysis"

Abstract: The comprehensive genomic analysis of ultra-low biomass samples to monitor Spacecraft, Cleanroom, Satellites, Probes, and other samples related to planetary protection requires high efficiency methods and reagents.  This includes stringent controls, ultra-high efficiency procedures, and DNA-free sampling equipment and reagents to circumvent the noise caused by the “Kitome” and “Extractome”. While current methods to sample, extract, and analyze DNA are routine, the efficiency data of such procedures are lacking and not documented. Additionally, the ability to obtain complete microbial lysis along with methods to amplify DNA from sub-picogram amounts of DNA prior to downstream analysis is critical . This including Metapolyzyme for space applications, Exopolyzyme, as well as techniques to pre-amplify ultra- low biomass samples using multiple displacement amplification (MDA) and Primary Template-directed Amplification (PTA) prior to downstream sequencing and analysis techniques.

Noah Fierer | University of Colorado Boulder
"Exploring the Limits of Microbial Life in Antarctic Soils"

Abstract: I will discuss recent work using cultivation-independent methods to explore microbial diversity in ice-free soils of Antarctica as a case study to highlight some of the challenges encountered when working with low biomass samples. I will also emphasize selected ‘best practices’ that should be followed to minimize contamination when conducting metagenomic analyses of environmental samples.

Jyothi Basapathi Raghavendra | University of Aberdeen
"DNA Sequencing at Picogram Level for Extremely Low Biomass Detection"

Maria-Paz Zorzano | Centro de Astrobiologia, INTA-CSIC, Spain
"Planetary Protection Protocols for Space Exploration: A Practical Introduction"

Abstract: Planetary protection is crucial in space exploration, safeguarding both the integrity of extraterrestrial life investigations and Earth’s biosphere from potentially hazardous extraterrestrial material. Current protocols emphasize bioburden reduction and contamination control, requiring rigorous sterilization and detection in cleanroom environments. This talk will review these established standards, pinpointing gaps and exploring how advanced molecular techniques, such as metagenomics, can enhance planetary protection standards. Through examples from recent space missions, we will discuss practical applications and assess the potential of new biological tools in this field.


10 a.m. Break
10:40 a.m. Session Four Presentations: Bioinformatics and Databases - Recording
Barbara Novak | NASA GeneLab
"NASA Open Science Data Repository: Microbe Data and Analysis Workflows"

Samrawit Gebre | NASA GeneLab
"Advancing Planetary Protection With SMCC: Leveraging the Space Microbial Culture Collection for Discovery and Access to Microbial Isolates"

Abstract: SMCC is a repository for collections of space microbes originated by NASA scientists and research PIs and offers digital (genomic, phenotypic, and rich metadata) and physical formats (the isolates themselves) of space microbes, which can be requested for research purposes. SMCC could be a critical tool in enhancing NASA's planetary protection efforts. By systematically identifying and cataloging isolates, researchers can better understand the diversity of microbial life associated with spacecraft and mission environments. This understanding is vital for assessing contamination risks and developing strategies to mitigate the forward contamination of other planetary bodies and backward contamination of Earth. SMCC provides access to microbial isolates to enable researchers from various disciplines to explore new hypotheses, conduct comparative studies, and contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of life in extreme environments.

Lorna Richardson | EMBL-EBI
"Free and Open Microbiome Data, Analysis and Resources at EMBL-EBI"

Abstract: EMBL-EBI is the home of big data in biology, empowering scientists to unravel complex information and drive discoveries that benefit humanity. MGnify, the microbiome data and analysis resource at EMBL-EBI, transforms microbiome-derived sequence data into robust, reproducible analysis products. We offer detailed taxonomic and functional profiles, biome-specific genome catalogues, and access to a staggering 2.4 billion non-redundant sequences in our protein database. These data products are ripe for biodiscovery mining. MGnify is dedicated to making microbiome research accessible with all public data, bioinformatic pipelines, and resources freely available, fostering an open research environment. In this talk, we will explore how these diverse data products are generated and how they can be harnessed in groundbreaking metagenomic research. We will also look to the future of MGnify and what the next release of our pipelines has in store.

Chiranjit Mukherjee | Battelle Memorial Institute
"Bioinformatic Noise Reduction Approaches for the Low-Biomass Samples"
12 p.m. Lunch

Afternoon Session

1:30 p.m. Breakout Session Three: Low Biomass
Breakout Session Four: Bioinformatics and Databases
4 p.m. Break
4:30 p.m. Summary of Breakout Sessions and Closing Remarks
5:30 p.m. End of Day Two

Thursday, Nov. 21

Morning Session

8 a.m. Session Introduction
8:25 a.m. Session Five Presentations: Technology Needs - Recording
Anna Maria Niewiadomska| Oxford Nanopore Technologies
"Towards Metagenomics of Anything, by Anyone, Anywhere With Oxford Nanopore"

Abstract: This presentation will highlight advancements in nanopore sequencing technology and its role in enabling metagenomics for microbial surveillance in diverse environments. We will discuss the latest methods, bioinformatics tools, and case studies that implement nanopore sequencing to detect and explore complex microbial communities, revealing insights into their composition and dynamics. These capabilities support our mission to enable the analysis of anything, by anyone, anywhere, particularly in the challenging contexts of space exploration.

Dominic O'Neil | QIAGEN
"Keeping it Clean - Challenges and Opportunities of Sequencing Low-Biomass Samples"

Abstract: Microbes are ubiquitous and can be found even in very clean environments. Understanding which microbes persist after cleaning or are present during production of ‘clean’ items can be very important to understanding and anticipating potential effects from these residual microbes. Current metagenomics tools are ideal for investigating these questions, as they provide a universal and mostly unbiased view of the microbial content of a sample. However, when dealing with extremely low-biomass samples, trace amounts of contamination can skew the results and extreme care must be taken to ensure accurate testing. I will discuss our experience with these challenges, and describe some of the methods we have developed to address them.

Emiley Eloe-Fadrosh | Joint Genome Institute
"Metagenome Analysis of Low-Biomass Samples: A JGI User Facility Perspective"

Abstract: The Department of Energy (DOE) Joint Genome Institute (JGI) handles thousands of samples for metagenomes and metatranscriptomes on an annual basis across diverse research projects. We have developed methods to support low-biomass samples ranging from ice cores to rock surfaces, and include shotgun sequencing and targeted cell enrichments with amplification. In addition to short-read sequencing, the JGI increasingly supports long-read sequencing for samples with ultra-low input DNA quantities. We will also describe a new single-cell amplification technique, primary template-directed amplification (PTA), that has been shown to generate near-complete genomes.

Kris Locken | Zymo Research 
"Exploring Microbial Life With Minimal DNA Input: Shotgun Metagenomics at Ultra-Low Biomass"

Abstract: Kris Locken is a molecular microbiologist specializing in the development and application of microbiome tools, standards and controls at Zymo Research, with a focus on advancing reliable solutions for low-biomass metagenomic analysis. He holds an M.S. in Microbiology and a B.S. in Molecular Cell Biology from California State University, Long Beach. During his studies, Kris investigated Ustilago maydis, known for its edible galls on maize, providing insights into fungal pathology and food science. He later characterized multiple antibiotic-sensitive mutants in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, contributing to our understanding of TOR kinase regulation in cellular transport and stress response. Before joining Zymo’s Microbiome team in 2019, Kris served as Quality Control Manager in two medical device manufacturing settings. His passion lies in exploring the microbial world and fostering the development of robust microbiological tools and standards for diverse research.

10 a.m. Break
10:40 a.m. Session Six Presentations: Human Health and the Built Environment - Recording

Chairs:
Christina Johnson | Chief, Space Biosciences Research Branch, Ames Research Center
Sandra Ortega Ugalde | ECLSS Engineer, ESA
Petra Rettberg | DLR

 Sarah Stahl Rommel | Spaceflight Microbiologist, Johnson Space Center
"Unlocking the Microbiome of the International Space Station"

Abstract: With the commencement of human occupation, the microbiome of the International Space Station (ISS) has been routinely monitored to assess risk to both spacecraft and crew. Historically, this monitoring has been achieved through onboard culture and ground-based analyses. While this approach has served to provide alerts to anomalies and overall confidence in the operational controls, the data are limited to the media type and growth conditions used; the bias toward the detection of culturable organisms has depicted an overall lack in biodiversity. As NASA moves to a focus on exploration beyond low-Earth orbit, it is critical to fully understand the microbiome of the ISS and its possible association with the noted positive influence on crew and vehicle health. The implementation of culture-independent, nanopore sequencing-based studies, both onboard the ISS and with returned ground samples, is revealing a more thorough depiction of the microbiome. Results from this study have implications for crew health, planetary protection, and controls used in future spacecraft systems. The ability to perform in situ profiling of the ISS microbiome is transforming how NASA assesses risk and is a critical tool towards monitoring the establishment of the environmental microbiome in exploration spacecraft.

Alison Laufer Halpin | Epidemiologist, CDC 
"The Role of Next Generation Sequencing for Healthcare-Associated Infection and Public Health Applications"

Jennie H. Kwon | Director for Healthcare Epidemiology and Infection Prevention, Washington University, St. Louis
"The Role of Built Environment as a Reservoir for Human Infection"

Abstract: The objectives of this talk are to understand the link between the human and environmental microbiome as a reservoir for infections, and discuss further directions to detect and prevent infections.

Erica Hartmann | Northwestern University
"Expanding Interpretation of Metagenomics"

Abstract: Metagenomic sequencing has many advantages over culture-based detection of microorganisms on spacecraft. However, this method has critical limitations surrounding sensitivity and ability to differentiate between live and dead cells. These factors are essential in interpreting sequencing results in the context of protecting astronaut health and preventing contamination. The goal of this talk is to discuss how advances in methods developed for surveillance of hospital environments can be applied to spacecraft.

Mika Salminen | Director General, Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare
"Public Health and Space"

Abstract: The objective of the talk is to discuss whether or not public health is a consideration for space exploration.

12 p.m. Lunch

Afternoon Session

1:30 p.m. Breakout Session: Technology Needs
Breakout Session: Human Health and the Built Environment 
4 p.m. Break
4:30 p.m. Summary of Breakout Sessions and Closing Comments
5:30 p.m. End of Day Three

Friday, Nov. 22

Morning Session

8 a.m. Session Introduction
8:30 a.m. Session Seven Presentations: Roadmap to Implementation - Recording

Lyle Whyte | McGill University
Karen Olsson-Francis | Professor of Geomicrobiology, School of Environment, Earth and Ecosystem Sciences, The Open University

Presentation Slides
10 a.m.  Break
10:30 a.m. Subgroup Breakouts and Summaries - Recording
12:30 p.m. Closing Comments 
1 p.m. Workshop Adjourned